James' House and Voldy's Great Doings

[fyredriftwood]

No: HPFGUIDX 41706

Haven't you ever thought that maybe we're looking too much into this? 
I mean, JKR confirmed that James played Chaser for an unknown team, 
and then later in the movie, James was a seeker. I think that we have 
to  take things into consideration and count them as two different 
items. THe movie WAS VERY DIFFERENT IN SOME PARTS than the book (ie: 
ron going into the dark forest instead of neville)... does that mean 
now we have to go on as to why Neville wasn't able to go and why Ron 
went? 

No we don't.

When Olivander goes into detail about all the "great" things Voldy 
has done, i think he's looking at the perspective at what he did, not 
who he did it to. (sorta hard to explain, sorry--it sounds good in my 
head though).

Think about it: Voldy was able to come up with ways to defy death, he 
influenced people to share his beliefs, he had wizards performing 
spells that were at one time almost impossible. THe amount of 
distruction he created was probably a lot (too hard to describe). So 
yes, this was a great accomplishment, just not "great" as in 
stupendious or excellent. 

--Fyre WOod