[HPforGrownups] Re: Snape and Neville

[NGUYEN-HOANG Anne]

No: HPFGUIDX 41863

---  Jasmine wrote:
>I think it's a nice theory, but I prefer to think that Snape had a
>run-in with Granny Longbottom in his youth! Think of how Lupin tells
>Neville what to make his Boggart look like...had the idea a little too
>quickly IIRC, also Snape took it very personally, don't you think?


LOL ^___^ after reading that post I'm going to have nightmares tonight
!! I talked about why Snape is so mean with my friend yesterday, and we
came up to that theorie. 

We all agree that Snape is incredibly smart. It's not a fan fantasy
since there's many facts which prove it.
He's not only the youngest professor but also the youngest headhouse at
Hogwards. and then Sirius told to the trio that Snape knew more curse in
his first year than half of the kids in their seventh. So he was
certainly one of the top Hogwards' students.

But James was the headboy, Lily headgirl and Sirius the second best
student after James. (Mcgonagall in PoA).

James and Sirius were good everywhere, and it seems to us that snape was
exceptionnally briliant in Potion, and maybe DADA, and a 'neville-like'
student in the other classes. that's the reason he wasn't the headboy...


So if he hates Neville so much it's because Neville reminds his youth as
the poor student whom everyone laught at. 


Annechan
ps : Fleur as the new DADA teacher... and why not lockhart with a dress
??? if she ever get a job, it will be at Hogsmeade, or maybe at Diagon
Alley...