Dumbledore does not HAVE to die - alternatives please

Felicia Rickmann feliciarickmann at dsl.pipex.com
Wed Jun 5 17:53:47 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 39421

> Maybe not die, but at least be unavailable.  (re: Gandalf) > I believe
that the foreshadowing in GoF is indicative of Dumbledore's death.  (I
should look up all the instances, it's more than just one!)
>
> Heidi R.


I suppose Dumbledore's death is the easy way to go about it.  I thought
about this some time ago as everyone seemed hell-bent on killing of D'dore *
via foreshadowing * in order to get Harry to his moment of destiny and I
thought - No, that's a copy out, its too easy - and JKR has not really
avoided tough actions before now.  The real puzzle would be how to go about
* life the universe and Potterverse * if she did NOT kill Dumbledore off.

Felicia
Still recovering from being the dedicatee of one of 2002's finest filks!! Ta
Coriolan!!








More information about the HPforGrownups archive