Ever So Evil McGonagall - NOT!!

[naamagatus]

No: HPFGUIDX 39621

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Amy Z" <aiz24 at h...> wrote:
> Faith--oops, I mean Naama--wrote:

Ouch!

> 
> >I've just had a stroke of genius:
> >
> >McGonagall *cannot* be an undercover DE, cannot be Ever So Evil -
> >because McGonagall appeared on the Foe Glass as Crouch!Moody's 
foe!!!
> >
> >So there!
> 
> Naama, Naama, Naama.  You really think a stroke of genius, or for 
that matter a stroke of common sense, is going to deter these ESE-
plotters?  They aren't naive.  As soon ask them to believe that Lee 
Harvey Oswald acted alone, or that those little numbers on the backs 
of highway signs aren't instructions for the invaders in black 
helicopters.
> 
> We know those DEs.  Just because they're all on Voldemort's side 
doesn't mean they're all on *one another's* side.  Maybe McGonagall 
was poised to stab Right-Hand Man Crouch Jr. in the back so that 
*she* could be Voldemort's number one, hence appeared in his Foe-
Glass as an enemy as implacable as Dumbledore.
> 

<sigh> I actually thought of that, but was too excited with my sudden 
insight to not post it immediately. 

> Or maybe Crouch never did recalibrate the Foe-Glass, it's still 
rigged to show *Moody's* enemies, and Snape, Dumbledore and 
McGonagall are *all* Ever So Evil.
> 

Ooooh, I love that! Although I'm starting to doubt your Faithfulness, 
Amy. There's probably an OFH badge flying in your direction this very 
minute. :-)

But - no, it can't work. D, S and M are closing in on Crouch!Moody, 
not on Real!Moody, who is safe in the trunk.

Naama
who should probably admit defeat too, but is enjoying the fight way 
too much to do that