[HPforGrownups] Would JKR make Lupin evil?

[Dave Hardenbrook]

No: HPFGUIDX 39667


Monday, June 10, 2002, 3:03:39 PM, alhewison wrote:

a> All the posts about *evil* Lupin have scared me. I can't help feeling 
a> a bit suspicious of one of favourite characters - that is despite all 
a> the valiant attempts at *proving* Lupin's innocence. BUT, although I 
a> cannot back up my argument with canon I doubt whether JKR would make 
a> Lupin evil.

I agree with everything you say... And I have full confidence that
everyone in Dumbledore's "Old Crowd" has truly earned his trust.

Frankly, I'm beginning to think, with due respect to all the wonderful
people on this list, that all these "Is <X> evil?" posts are largely a vent
for all the boredom of waiting for Book 5... And I feel it as much as
anybody -- I almost started a "Is Nearly-Headless Nick evil?" thread. :)

-- 
Dave

P.S. If it turns out that Nearly-Headless Nick *is* evil, remember,
      you heard it here first. :) :)