book differences & Canon, was Gringotts vaults
datalaur
datalaur at yahoo.com
Sun Jun 23 01:52:55 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 40219
> Gretchen replied:
> > I checked my US addition of PoA and
> > the vault number is not in the letter from Sirius to Harry.
sarah:
> Thanks for the reply, Gretchen. It's interesting that Black's
vault # isn't listed in the US edition.
I just recently heard the Stephen Fry tapes of HPSS and it seems like
there are a lot of differences between the English and American books
(assuming the tapes are made directly from the English written
version). I had thought it was of the "loo to bathroom, fringe to
bangs" type of change but it seems quite a bit more than that. (I
had wondered why people quoted which version/chapter and page -- now
I know.) I'm tempted to sit there with a book and compare to the
tape.
Can anyone discuss how the books wound up so different -- did JKR re-
edit for the American version? How are people dealing with the canon
changes wrought by the differences? This "vault 711" is just one
detail that could have been rather important. If one buys into
the "every detail is important" theory. If so... is it plausible
that the American version (which is presumably a later version) is a
somehow "better", she-got-a-second-chance-to-fix-things version? In
other words, does one have more 'weight' than the other in canon?
very curious,
laur
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive