re Hagrid's fate (was Defense of Hagrid)

[ftah3]

No: HPFGUIDX 40277

Richelle wrote:
> I also think that Hagrid will be the character that 
dies in Book 
> 5.  To me it seems like he was created as a character that children 
would like, 
> and as the books reach higher levels, the purpose of his character 
will cease 
> to exist.  

Hmm, I think you've got a good point that Hagrid's appeal so far
would 
endear him to children; and if the books continue to evoke themes of 
'growing up,' Hagrid would be a definite potential lamb to sacrifice 
to the deity of lost innocence.

On the other hand, I think he might be developing into a role beyond 
the one he's played so far (friend of the kids, adult version of 
innocence), based on implications at the end of GoF.  GoF contained 
discussion about the need, in light of Voldemort's efforts to return 
to power, to develop or cut relations with non-human magical types.  
I.e., cut relations with the Dementors, because they're tailor-made 
Voldemort allies, and leaving them in control of Azkaban is not the 
best idea.  Mention was also made of courting the giants as allies of 
the good guys.  Giants are typically a violent people who don't care 
to mix with the outside world, but Dumbledore (er, I think it was; 
suddenly not sure) seemed to think that they would be on the fence - 
as likely to side with the good as with the bad guys; he tries to 
convince Fudge to send a delegation to open relations with them.

At the end of GoF, Dumbledore looks to be revving up to act on 
different fronts - is sending out a call to his old crew; has 
interesting secret uses for Snape.  And if Dumbledore decided to try 
to make nice with the giants despite lack of support from the
Ministry 
of Magic, Hagrid and the Beaubaxtons headmistress, who are both 
half-giant, half-wizarding human, would be logical intermediaries.

If Hagrid became a diplomat to the giants, he would possibly be 
removed from the Hogwarts scene, which would effectively end his 
previous role, which depended on his interaction with Harry et al. 
He 
would then grow into another role would have long-reaching 
implications, and potentially require that he stay alive through the 
end of the series. 

But if he does remain in the role he has played to this point, I do 
agree with you, Richelle, that his days could be numbered.  And I 
would cry if that were the case.  :(  I like Hagrid a lot!

Mahoney