Divination

brewpub44 brewpub44 at snet.net
Sun Mar 17 22:29:50 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 36633

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Jake Storm" <that1guy_hp at h...> wrote:
> >From: ruben at s...
> >So, why does Dumbledore keep [Trelawney], when it's clear she's 
not very 
> >reliable?
> >(whether her fault or not, she's certainly not reliable - and not
> >particularly bright either).
> 

I'm surprised no one thinks as I do, that Trelawney is the only 
Divination teacher Dumbledore can get, just like DADA but for a 
different reason.

As has been stated in the past on this list, wizards don't think very 
much of divination, hence I doubt many are into it, and if they are, 
they probably aren't very popular. I suspect they live somewhat 
isolated lives, either because they are shunned by other wizards (who 
wants to hear they are dying every twelve minutes?), or because they 
need to shun others (because every time they meet someone they have a 
vision that person will die in twelve minutes). It must be a horrible 
existing for a seer. 

So it must be hard to get a good divination teacher. So Hogwarts has 
Trelawney.

A Barkeep in Diagon Alley





More information about the HPforGrownups archive