[HPforGrownups] Re: Still-Life With Memory Charm

[Amanda]

No: HPFGUIDX 36815

I am truly sorry if this has been mentioned, really. But I've been waiting
until I get time enough to do justice to the Still Life post, and haven't
really followed all the Neville threads. But something struck me, when
someone posted an analysis of how memory charms seem to affect people.

One of the examples was Neville, just coming out of the classroom after
Moody held him back. Neville is clumsy and forgetful, but not dopey; this is
distinctly odd. So---->Has anyone suggested (as I am), that Crouch/Moody was
the perpetrator of the crime against the Longbottoms, that he saw Neville's
reaction to his class, and held Neville back to reinforce the memory charm
that he himself cast, years ago? Neville is loopy in the hall because he's
*just* had a memory charm cast on him.

Whatcha think? Am I repeating someone?

--Amanda