TBAY - Snape the Killer

marinafrants rusalka at ix.netcom.com
Sat Nov 23 20:27:43 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 47038

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "dicentra63" <dicentra at x> wrote:
> Dicentra rushes from the back room, Stoned!Harry trailing in her 
wake.
> As she emerges into the main room of the tavern, she sees George,
> placidly drying glasses with a towel and stacking them on the 
shelf.
> 
> "It's all YOUR fault!" she shrieks as she comes to a sudden stop. 
> Stoned!Harry plows into her, nearly knocking her over.  "You and 
your
> denial of Banginess!  You've got all those Snapetheorists thinking
> their dear Severus couldn't have been a genuine Death Eater."  She
> advances on George threateningly.  George backs slowly into a 
corner.
> 

"Now, wait a minute, Dicey!" he says.  "You can't blame this mess on 
me, I just pour the drinks.  I'm not responsible for what the 
patrons might say in a drunken stupor.  And *I*, for one, have never 
claimed that Snape was not a genuine DE.  Heck, one of my most 
fundamental tenets is that Snape joined the DE's of his own free 
will, knowing full well the evil activities they were getting up to, 
and believing that he was okay with that.  I claim that his moral 
conversion was gradual rather than instanteously Bangy, but I never 
lose sight of the fact that you can't have a moral conversion unless 
there was actually something wrong with your morals to begin with.  
I'm not at all opposed a Snape who did horrible things in his 
youth.  I'm not even opposed to GleefulSadist!Snape, even though 
Marina is."

"Uhm.  Right.  Okay."  Dicey takes a deep breath and calms 
down.  "I'm glad we cleared that up.  I'm going to go talk to Wendy 
now."

"Have fun," George says cheerfully.  "Would you like a pina colada 
on the house before you go?"

Marina
rusalka at ix.netcom.com






More information about the HPforGrownups archive