Harry's vault key

Jacqui jasonjacqui at yahoo.com
Sat Nov 30 03:37:46 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 47446

> Yes, I think he got it from Dumbledore. We don't know whether 
> Dumbledore was at Potters' that night. Even if he wasn't there 
either 
> Lily or James could give him the key earlier. I don't know, maybe 
> when they went into hiding, just in case. I am inclined to think 
that 
> money's indeed Harry's inheritance from his parents. Whom do you 
> think these money is from?
> Alla

I am not saying that it definately came from some where else, I am 
just trying to figure out how Hagrid or Dumbledore got the key in the 
first place.  It doesn't sit well with me.  Even if Dumbledore was 
there that night, Lily and James had no reason to think that their 
lives were about to end, therefor they would have no reason to give 
Dumbledore their vault key.  In SS when Hagrid writes to Dumbledore 
saying he is going to take Harry to get his school things in london, 
that gives me the impression that he may have gotten it from 
Dumbledore...But I still can't figure out where Dumbledore got 
it...Any one have some ideas?

Jacqui






More information about the HPforGrownups archive