obstruction of justice
pippin_999
foxmoth at qnet.com
Thu Oct 3 15:28:01 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 44857
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "brainattic" <brainattic at y...> wrote:
> According to the Lexicon, Riddle murdered his father's family
during the summer vacation before his seventh year. Why wasn't
he caught by the Ministry for violating the Decree for the
Restriction of Underage Wizardry?<<
Riddle could have turned seventeen during his sixth year, just as
Fred and George did. JKR has also said that when Harry turns
seventeen he'll be allowed to do magic outside school.
Also, the Lexicon dates conform to canon but are not the only
possible interpretation. By making slightly different assumptions,
one can devise other chronologies that fit the canon just as well
and make Riddle a year or so older than Steve does.
>> Also, since they seem to be able to pinpoint your exact
location and what kind of spell you did, shouldn't they have
known that he perfomed the Avada Kedavra Curse? <<
They don't seem to have known that Frank Bryce was killed by
magic, either. (We know he was, because he came out of
Voldemort's wand). In fact, Dumbledore says that the Ministry
paid little attention to Frank's disappearance even after they were
told it might be connected to Voldemort.
The fact that the Riddles' deaths were the subject of a prolonged
investigation by the Muggle authorities most likely means
the Ministry never connected their deaths with magic at all, much
less Tom Riddle. Had the ministry been involved, they would
have covered up the whole thing with memory charms, and there
would have been no mystery for the village to muddle over for fifty
years.
Concerning Fred, George and Lily, the Decree for the
Reasonable Restriction of Underage Sorcery says "not
permitted to perform spells" at least according to Mme. Hopkirk.
This is a loophole plenty big enough for a Weasley to wiggle
through, since the creation of canary creams and ton-tongue
toffees would most likely involve potion-making not spell-work.
As for Lily's teacups that turn into rats, she could have charmed
them while she was at school--another loophole. Or maybe it
was not magic at all but sleight of hand --- and the rat was Peter!
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive