Why Snape may know what he knows WAS Re: The Gleam Revisited
bugaloo37
crussell at arkansas.net
Wed Oct 9 18:13:58 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 45136
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "marinafrants" <rusalka at i...> wrote:
> <snip>
> It is not "metathinking" to claim that Harry is the hero of the
> books. The books are called "Harry Potter and --"; with the
> exception of one chapter in GoF and one scene in PS/SS, they're all
> written from his point of view. In every book, he's the one who
> takes the decisive action that saves the situation (even if all he
> can manage in GoF is a partial save). However fascinating we might
> find Snape, or Dumbledore, or Sirius, or Avery, or Mrs LeStrange,
> the books are not about them; they're about Harry.
>
Thank you for the above statement concerning Harry's importance. I
have been trying to come up with a way to say exactly the same
thing. There are some very interesting unknowns concerning Snape,
Dumbledore, Lupin, Sirius, Hagrid: Who are they really? What are
they really up to? and in some cases: where do their loyalties lie?
As I've said before, I consider the HP series mystery novels-
supplying small amounts of clues which of course can lead to all
kinds of assumptions and speculations. But one thing that I as a
reader am sure of (of course, this is only my opinion) is this:
Harry Potter is the center of my perception of the WW. It is
through his eyes that I see everything;therefore, my opinion is
tainted by his. Is there more to Snape than meets the eye? Sure-
and I believe that Harry is begining to think so too. Does
Dumbledore know more than he lets on? Yes-definitely, and Harry
knows this too. Is Harry for whatever reason Voldemort's primary
target? Yes- and again, Harry knows this too-but just like us, he
does not know why. Is it necessary for him to know why at this
point? I say no-who knows what effect it might have on Harry? But
if we the reader knew-the series would effectively be over. As long
as Harry is in the dark, so are we. That's what keeps me reading.
This does not mean we cannot have lots of fun trying to figure things
out. I guess what I am saying is this: coming up with theories is
fun-it's what keeps life interesting. But please do not try and tell
me that Harry's importance to the series will not come till the end
of the series-IMO, that just doesn't make any sense.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive