[HPforGrownups] Re: Why the Order of the Phoenix?

[Vinnia Chrysshallie]

No: HPFGUIDX 45550

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., kathrynbav at a... wrote:
<snip>
So, what does all this mean for Book Five:  *Harry
Potter and the Order of the Phoenix*?  If my
assumptions above are even remotely correct, then
could it not be argued:
5)  Order of the Phoenix - Secret organization created
by, and for the explicit use of, a newly resurrected
Voldemort. A new name for a new wave of destruction
that will wash across the WW.
...
A phoenix is a bird that rises from the ashes of its
own destruction:

<snip>
>>>


Hi, this is my first post, and I know this must have
been discussed a lot of times.  However I have a
different opinion so I thought Id give you all
something different to ponder ;)

What if the order of Phoenix is not a group of people
at all? 

What if it concerned the lifecycle of which the
phoenix feather was taken from Fawkes? We dont know
if the feathers were given at the same time. If they
were taken from a different cycle, then even though
the wands are brother, they are sort of step-brother?
Sorry I cant find the right phrase! :<

I think the fact that phoenixes keep regenerating will
play an important part, otherwise why would Rowling
mention it? The fact that Harrys and Voldemorts wand
cant battle each other means that Harry has to defeat
Voldemort wandless. This is not going to happen until
book 7.

I believe in book 5, Harry would face Voldemort once
again, and the very thing that saves Harry would be
the fact that his phoenix feather is from a different
lifecycle with Voldemorts. Hence the order of phoenix
effect.
Well, thats my two cents. 



Vinnia
who wonder what the experts in HPFGU would say about
her theory

http://careers.yahoo.com.au - Yahoo! Careers
- 1,000's of jobs waiting online for you!