What about Harry?
fruhu
iwant12 at hotmail.com
Fri Sep 6 08:18:08 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 43694
Good morning!
I'm prepared to bet this has been discussed here already, but all the
same I can't find it in the archives.
What will happen to Harry at the end of book seven? Is it likely that
he will die, will he become an auror one day, anything else? The
thing is that JKR has in numerous interviews (all found at
HPGalleries, I can't link to them now because the site is down) said
things like: "What makes you think I will not kill him [Harry] then?"
and "So you are sure he will not die?" What makes her say these
things? At first I thought that's the way it has to be, Harry will
die because it's necessary for the plot. But if she were really
planning to kill him, I don't think she would talk about it like
that. Now I simply think she said that to tease the interviewer or
something.
But another question is do we want Harry to die. In a way yes,
because if he doesn't there'll always be the urge to know what
happened to him (then again that can be good food for fantasies). But
on the other hand... if he dies it should be written in a way that
still leaves the reader with a good feeling. The book The Amber
Spyglass, for example (3rd book in His Dark Materials trilogy by
Philip Pullman) has a very disturbing ending. The books really
peirced my heart in a way no other books have, I think, and when I
came to the ending it still felt like that, but in a bad way. That's
not how it's supposed to be.
Greetings from
Fru Hu
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive