Color Symbolism, Snape's past
bugaloo37
crussell at arkansas.net
Tue Sep 24 13:58:36 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 44399
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., eloiseherisson at a... wrote:
><snip> And although McGonagall witnesses Crouch Jr's confession and
Snape's 'coming out', Dumbledore doesn't let her witness Sirius'
transformation, so he does seem to play some of his cards close to
his chest.
I dunno. Perhaps she knows, perhaps she doesn't.
>
> Eloise
I definitely agree with the fact that Dumbledore does not reveal
everything he knows-not even to McGonagall-who seems to be his
closest ally at this point. In GoF, he asks Molly Weasley for their
family's support, IMO, it seems, in order to reassure himself. I
could, of course, be misinterpreting this scene. But it seems to me
Dumbledore is in command and is assessing his troops as it were. As
far as I know (please correct me, if I am wrong), Dumbledore has only
mentioned having complete trust in two characters: Hagrid and
strangely enough, Snape. What this implicit trust he has is based on-
we have yet to find out. I know there is some disagreement out there
concerning the extent of Dumbledore's abilities/knowledge but I tend
to side with those who feel that what has been revealed about him is
only the tip of the iceberg.
bugaloo37
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive