Evil!McGonagall/Dumbledore/Snape (was: Re: Harry and Snape and Dumbledore)

[Audra1976 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 55119

grosich at nyc.rr.com writes:
> As for Snape or Dumbledore et al. being evil.  I don't buy it for 2 reasons. 
>  One, Harry cannot live in a world where no one is what they seem and 
> everyone is evil.  Too depressing and a bit pointless.  Second, the foe 
> glass.  Snape, Dumbledore and McGonagall appeared very clearly in 
> Crouch-Moody's foe glass.  If one of them was really on Voldemort's side, 
> their face wouldn't appear.  I don't have reason (yet!) to doubt the 
> accuracy of the foe glass.  And Snape's image in it was mentioned more than 
> once.

Me:
But isn't it possible for McGonagall, Dumbledore, or Snape to be evil, yet 
still be an enemy of Barty Crouch?  There can be a lot of different factions 
on the sides of both good and evil.

-Audra-


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]