Hermione's Birthday; SHIP (FITD)

[grace701]

No: HPFGUIDX 55365


> Petra: <<<<<<<<Ah but in JKR's books how do you tell 
> the foreshadowing from the red herrings?  
> The only difference between foreshadowing 
> and red herring is that the former is 
> accurate and the latter is misleading.  
> Which is to say that until the big reveal, 
> a good mystery leaves the readers utterly 
> unable to tell which is which.>>>>>>>>>>>

Penny wrote: 
>>*nods*   Yep, I agree with Petra on this point.  I think GoF 
>>foreshadows R-------->Hr and that it foreshadows Hr-------------
>>Ha.  Clearly, Katy would disagree and so would Chris Columbus.  
>>Remains to be seen how it all plays out, and I sincerely doubt it 
>>will all be resolved by the end of OoP in any case.


Question is is JKR foreshadowing a Ha------------>Hr.  If not it 
will lead us to a love triangle and maybe even a couple of third 
wheelers:  Ginny------>Ha, Neville--------->Hr or Ginny, and who 
knows whoe else.  I bet love potions are going to be slipped in one 
of the books.

Greicy