Longbottoms, St. Mungos, Lucius, and Celestina...

[gishstar1]

No: HPFGUIDX 56156

Ok, so I'm new to the 'group' but I have some huge questions that 
I've wanted to discuss with people who are just as obsessed and 
concerned as I am and I wasn't sure where to look up past topics... 
so if this one has already been discussed I deeply apologize and 
just direct me in the right direction... ha.. ok ... so here goes. 

I 
have a few theories... but this is one of them that I have been 
longing to discuss with others. Ok, so we know that the Longbottoms 
are at Saint Mungos... because someone put the crucatious curse on 
them and it's heavily affected them and their memeories... I have 
reason so suspect that Neville was hit with "obilivate" (sp?) as a 
young baby... now... who would want a baby to forget something? AND! 
what could the effects of a memory spell have on a baby? ... J.K. 
keeps mentioning and reminding us that Neville is very forgetful... 
hmmm... there's got to be a reason for that. Ok... something else to 
muse upon... Saint Mungos... we know that the Longbottoms are at the 
hospital can't remember a thing, or themselves... I think someone is 
preventing them from getting better. Why would I say that? 

My theory 
is becaues Lucius Malfoy donates to Saint Mungos Hospital. (as 
stated in Book 4 at the start of the Quidditch World Cup by 
Cornelius Fudge) and who do we all know that Mr. Malfoy is 
associated with??? Voldemort! Now, is Lucius donating out of the 
pureness of his heart? (ha!) or is it because he's paying to make 
sure that certain somebodies don't recover from their 'injuries'. 
Let it be known as well, Voldemort said (and we can never take what 
he says serious because he's almost always lying... but we are very 
certain that he is aware when people are lying to him) that once 
someone has had a memory charm put on them and to alter that to make 
them remember harms that person and they are no longer ... uhmm i 
can't think of the word... but it's not good... they're like not 
people anymore... but like they're memories are permantly damaged 
and they aren't (he put it as useful) well, they aren't human 
anymore... they just have perpetual Alzheimers... anycrud... So... 
to make Neville remember would be putting him in danger of his 
life... that's what I'm getting from that statement... BUT we also 
know of another certain somebody that is donating to this hospital.. 
Celestina Warbeck and if she's donating and Lucius is donating... I 
dont think anyone by the names of Mr. and Mrs. Longbottom are going 
to ever get better... *sob* ... oh well. well not 'oh well' but 
yeah... In 'OoP' maybe we'll find out maybe we won't... oh and let 
me know if this was already discussed... thanks..  

Ari