Still wondering about ghosts

evangelina839 evangelina839 at yahoo.se
Sun Aug 3 21:52:15 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 75111

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Miss Tery" <miss_teriously at y...> wrote:
> I once read an interview with JKR, one of the questions was why some 
> wizards become ghosts and some don't. She smiled and answered that in 
> book 5 the answer to that question would become clearer. Well now 
> I've read the Order of the Phoenix and I think I was just as 
> disappointed as Harry Potter about the explanation that Nearly 
> Headless Nick gave, because although he is dead, he doesn't know a 
> thing. Have you got any ideas about this subject?
> 
> Miss Tery

I, too, expected a *lot* more information on ghosts, but I think there is more there in 
Harry's conversation with Nick if you read between the lines. Especially if you add 
Nicolas Flamel's view on the subject... death being the next big adventure and all... 
hm, well *why* some wizards become ghosts is answered, it's by choice. I expected to 
get more questions answered though. ;)

Lori said: "The only one I question is Moaning Myrtle, I don't think she choose to stay 
I think she was made to stay."

I always thought that Myrtle wanted to get back at Olive Hornby (some unfinished 
business...), as her first mission in death was to stalk Olive everywhere she went. :)

evangelina





More information about the HPforGrownups archive