Harry Has The Right To Know The Whole Truth
Fred Waldrop
fredwaldrop at yahoo.com
Thu Aug 7 05:30:48 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 75787
Buttercup wrote:
4. Harry should be allowed membership into the Order
and be able to attend their meetings. After all, the
purposes of the organization is to stop Voldemort, and
only Harry can do that. <<
=====================================================================
"backstagemystic" <idcre at i...> wrote:
Harry is NOT emotionally mature enough to be part of the Order
(especially now, as he's overwhelmed with anger, guilt and grief).
Plus, he has NOT mastered keeping Voldemort out of his mind. With
Harry sitting there, one might as well hookup a remote cam and
speaker to allow Voldie to eavesdrop on the meetings.
=====================================================================
Hello all, Fred Waldrop here;
To be honest, unless some think that Harry should NEVER be in the
OotP, and seeing he only has 2 years to "mature emotionally" enough,
it is a now or never kind of thing.
While I will agree that Harry might not need to join the OotP in the
next book, he sorta needs to be kept in the loop a lot better in the
next 2 books. Or, Potterworld needs to hope and pray the prophecy
does NOT include the boy who lives at #4 Prievet drive. Because if he
is told as much (or as little) in the next 2 books, (the very LAST 2
books), he will most certianly get himself killed from ignorance.
Ignorance that comes from not being told the truth, and being told
only half truths when he is told the truth. To be left to fill in the
blanks himself with the answer he comes up with.
This is what Harry gets throughout Ootp, mostly half truths, and we
all know how well that turned out. From the "there is nothing in MoM
for you Potter", to "you need to learn occlumency because you and V
are.... connected".
If someone, or anyone as far as that goes, would have sat Harry down
and told him ALL the truth, while the book would not have been as
good, Harry at least would have been able to understand COMPLEATLY
what was going on. Not just what he thought was going on, or what he
was assumeing was going on, but what exactly was going on.
Fred Waldrop
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive