Weasley ages (was:Re: How Old Are Snape/Sirius/Lupin/James/Peter?)

[bibphile]

No: HPFGUIDX 76197

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "meltowne" <meltowne at y...> 
wrote:
> But the reference in PoA is that they won the Quiddich Cup when 
> Charlie was there - the 7 years refers to the House Cup - they 
could  have won the Quiddich Cup without winning the House Cup, 
meaning  Charlie could have been as little as 7 years older the HRH, 
and 3 years older than Percy.  So we have a range of ages for them 
without  being inconsistant.
>
No.  I'm pretty sure it was in PS that it had been seven years since 
they won the House Cup and in PoA, it had been seven years since 
they won the Quidditch Cup.  I know they won the house cup in PS and 
CoS.

Besides, I'm pretty sure PoA was the first time they won the 
Quidditch cup since Oliver had been on the team.  If Charlie was 
only three years older than Percy, Oliver would have been a fourh 
year the last time they won the Quidditch cup.  I seriouly doubt his 
fifth year was his first year on the team since he was captain.

bibphile