is there a reason?

[Hagrid]

No: HPFGUIDX 77357

--- IAmLordCassandra wrote:
> Casey writes: 
> > 
> > is there a reason besides how they make you feel that 
> > dumbledore hates dementors? i mean does he have bad things in his 
> > past or does he just not like them? i think there has to be 
> > something deeper to this... or maybe im just reading too deeply 
> > into this!
> 
> Cassie:  I've always felt it was because of people's (mainly 
Fudge's) naive trust in them.  I'm not sure where (I'm pretty sure it 
was GoF), but somewhere Dumbledore tells Fudge something along the 
lines of "They (the Dementors) will not remain loyal to you. 
Voldemort can give them more, etc...etc.."  
> 
> Whatever the reasons...they must be very foul for kind, trusting 
> Dumbledore to not like them.  

AUSSIE: I think it is in "Fantastic Creatures and Where to Find Them" 
that Dementors are said to be, not a natural creature, but a being 
devised by wizards to be used as a weapon against other wizarding 
folk. Some of the most dangerous Creatures were developed in this 
means, so there are a lot of arguements in the WW as to keeping 
Dementors in a list of Sentient Beings or not. 
Arguements may say something like, "OK, so you want to keep 
Dementors. Fine, but let's make them only 2 parts Vampire instead of 
7 ... and add a bit of something safer ... like Flubberworms."

aussie