Getting the secret out... PP instead of SB

melclaros melclaros at yahoo.com
Mon Aug 18 19:41:53 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 77850

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "meltowne" <meltowne at y...> 
wrote:
 
> What I wondor is how members of the order found out where they 
were.  
> I would assume they had 3 or 4 options before they cast the 
fidelius, 
> and then informed the secret keeper of that choice.  Since the 
charm 
> was cast only shortly before they were killed, I would assume Harry 
> was directly protected by it, meaning that for Hagrid to rescue 
him, 
> Hagrid had to know the location.  That, of course, means someone 
told 
> Hagrid where they were - yes, we know Dumbledore sent him, but 
since 
> Dumbledore was not the secret keeper, he couldn't have told Hagrid 
> where to go - just that he needed to go!


Yes! Yes, see??? This is what I can NOT figure out. If ONLY PP knew 
how to find the Potters, even if the HOUSE was in plain view, then 
How did Hagrid (and whoever else showed up in those missing hours) 
manage to find James and Lily's bodies (unless the charm is broken at 
death) and Harry? (Who was alive so if the death/charmbreak is true 
would have been INVISIBLE.)
 
Melpomene (my brain hurts!)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive