Pondering that Secret Keeper thing

[scoutmom21113]

No: HPFGUIDX 77920

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Kelly" <keltobin at y...> wrote:

Kelly:
<snip> > Here is the most logical explaination I can arrive at:
> Sirius, who was told the location by Peter, went into the ruins of 
> the house and came out with baby Harry.  He then turned Harry over 
to Hagrid (along with his motorbike).  

RB: 
I couldn't find the passage in a quick look through SS/PS, but I 
thought I read that Hagrid told Harry (Dumbledore, maybe) he got to 
the house before the muggles did, and while he was there Sirius 
arrived and loaned Hagrid his motorcycle.  Does anyone else remember 
this?  Or is it movie contamination?

Kelly: 
> The other explaination is that JKR, while writing the first book, 
had no idea people would be picking it apart to this degree and it 
is simply an oversight...

This may be the answer.  Each book has gotten more detailed, so JKR 
may not have thought this through as much as we have.  Afterall, she 
didn't have dozens of people debating each point for her <g>.

Ravenclaw Bookworm