POA Dementor Kiss on Harry - New Question

KathyK zanelupin at yahoo.com
Thu Aug 21 17:03:04 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 78276

> Severus here:  
> 
> Or he told them to do it and Harry drove them away with his 
> patronus.  And since Harry survived, Fudge had to cover his butt.   
> I believe Fudge doesn't care for Harry or if he survives at all, to 
> Fudge, he is just bait to get Sirius to show at Hogwarts.  And this 
> could be backed up in GoF, Fudge was helping Harry, so he could win 
> the TWC and be the one to touch the cup.  Does Fudge know that 
> Wormtail is still alive and tried to catch Sirius before he got to 
> Wormtail?  I think Fudge is a DE sympathiser (sp?).


Just a quick point:

In GoF, Harry got help (or was offered help) from several people:

Crouch/Moody helped Harry with every task, even though Harry didn't 
know it.  And he manipulated the following people into giving Harry a 
hand so Harry would win.

Hagrid told Harry about the dragons.  Though Crouch/Moody tells Harry 
that he nudged Hagrid to reveal that.

Cedric shared information (again from Crouch/Moody) with Harry about 
the egg.

Dobby told Harry about the gillyweed, which he learned about from 
Crouch/Moody.

Ludo Bagman, AFAIK the only one not being manipulated by 
Crouch/Moody, having made a bet that Harry would win the Tournament, 
offered to help Harry.  Harry did not take him up.

Oh, actually, Ron and Hermione helped out with researching and 
practicing.  I don't think Crouch had anything to do with that, 
specifically.


I don't recall Fudge doing anything to ensure Harry's getting to the 
Cup.

KathyK (who thinks Fudge is many things, but not a Death Eater or a 
Voldemort Supporter)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive