Where is Snape????

laylalast liliana at worldonline.nl
Thu Aug 21 18:04:14 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 78339

Talisman, hanging by her toes from the monitor, suggests:
 
 > Usually vampires (even double agent spy ones) don't show up in 
 > photographs.

Now me, about to throw a few specks of cold water:

We know that Snape became a spy before Voldemort's downfall, so 
before Sirius was convicted to Azkaban for the murder of Harry's 
parents. From the moment Sirius came into Harry's life he never let 
on that he knew that Snape was a spy, in fact everything he said or 
did with regard to Snape is in contradiction with this (as well as 
the actions and stories of others, like Remus). 

So, IMO, Snape should not show in that picture, regardless of whether 
he is a vampire or not. At that time he was not a member of the Order 
in the same way as he is now.
In fact, I should have become very suspicious if he had been in the 
picture as well.

Laylalast (aka Lilian)







More information about the HPforGrownups archive