FUDGE IS A DE!!!!
severusbook4
severusbook4 at yahoo.com
Mon Aug 25 17:08:43 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 78694
Maneelyfh and I have been comparing our opinions on Fudge and his
convenient stance on LV not being back untill the end of OotP.
I have pulled our findings and it seems, astonishingly, that Fudge
is in leagues with LV.
First in PoA, Fudge is at the Leaky Cauldren to greet Harry and to
make sure he is O.K., and that his underage misuse of magic against
his aunt was no big thing. This sounds fine until later.
Second in PoA, the dementors left their posts to invade the
Quidditch match and they seemed very interested in Harry, they were
all looking up at him, no one else. Did they do this at Fudge's
request? We think so.
Third in PoA, the dementors try to administer the kiss to Harry and
perhaps to Hermione. Would the dementors act on their own accord,
and go against orders? The only one that was to get the kiss
immediately was Sirius, but there is no mention of this. The
dementors receive their orders from who? Fudge, that's who. And
how would he know that the dementors had tried to "kiss" Harry in
the first place, the only one who knew was Harry and he remained
unconscious until Fudge had already told DD about the
attempted "kiss". Fudge knew because he had orered it, and to save
face, he had to order the dementors back to Azkaban, even after
Sirius had escaped once again.
Fourth in PoA, If Fudge thought Harry and friends were actually
under Sirius' control, he would still believe Harry and friends were
in danger from Sirius, and the dementors would have remained, even
against DD wishes. Harry and friends were the only one's defending
Sirius, and Snape and Fudge said that they had be cunfunded, so how
would Fudge know Sirius would not attempt to kill Harry again,
because Fudge knew Sirius was after Peter in the first place, and
Fudge was trying to protect Peter. Peter had escaped, as Harry,
Hermione, and Ron told them. So it was safe for the dementors to go
back to Azkaban, Peter was safe from Sirius.
Fifth in GoF, the pensieve incident, Karkaroff states "...we never
knew the names of everyone of our fellows...He alone knew who we all
were..." This statement gives further proof of the possibility of
Fudge being a DE, because if know one knew except LV, then one one
could rat him out.
Sixth in GoF, Crouch would have been getting orders from Fudge
during the Tri Wizard Tourney and that would be the reason he helped
Harry with the tasks, whether it was trough Cedrick, Moody, or
himself. Crouch told Cedrick how to read the second clue and in
turn knew Cedrick would tell Harry, since Harry had helped him with
the first task.
Seventh in GoF, Moody was hired by DD, who else would know except
the MOM? Fudge then told Crouch Jr. to take Moody's place in order
to facilitate Harry winning the cup. Why else would Fudge have the
kiss administered so quickly to Crouch Jr. after his capture? So
Crouch Jr. could not tell of Fudge's involvement.
Eighth in GoF, LV states "...I shall have all my devoted servants
returned to me, and an army of creatures whom all fear." Could LV
be speaking of the creatures that Luna Lovegood says Fudge is
secretly breeding?
And finally in OotP, Umbridge, who sent the dementors to "kiss"
Harry. Umbridge, who had all the power to do what she wanted at
Hogwarts. Umbridge, who undermined the DADA class so the students
could not stand a chance in a battle against the dark arts. Which
would make it easier for LV to regain power, there would be no one
trained to stop him. Where did she receive this power? Fudge,he
apointed her high inquisitor at Hogwarts and he signed all the
decrie's <sp?> she wanted. Also, Fudge's accusation of DD creating
an army to over throw him is just a clever cover up, (even though DD
turned the job down), so he could do as he pleased.
O.K., just one more. Why did Fudge try to punish Harry for the
underage use of magic so ferverently in the MOM? Harry had a
serious reason for that use of magic, but all the other times,
Dobbies levitation of the cake, Harry blowing up his aunt, had been
delt with very lightly. Fudge had a means to further discredit Harry
and possibly have him removed from the situation totally. By
further discredit of Harry, it is easier to discredit DD by
associating them so closely, ie; "DD must be crazy to believe this
boy. Look at all he's done." Fudge tried to use this to his
advantage through the local paper.
One final question, does everyone think Fudge is an idiot? He did
become MOM some how. Do you think that he would be this clueless in
all the signs pointing to LV's resurection? Fudge knew, but he also
knew LV needed time to gain his army back, and Fudge was able to
deny his existence with plausible deniability.
Severus "I'm not a DE, He is." Snape
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive