My Post Again

[maneelyfh]

No: HPFGUIDX 78835

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Carolina <silmariel at t...> wrote:
> Severus:
> 
> << O.K. Let me start by saying that there is no real proof to
>  support the Harry is gay train of thought, but there is quite a
>  bit to support that he is straight.>>
> 
> You take that as an axiom, that leads you to believe the next quote:
> 
> <<My opinion that Harry is straight is based on written proof but 
is 
> flamed while some ones homosexual fantasy, that has no reason to be 
> in a book discussion forum, is alright?>>
> 
> Here is the point. The written proof is the same for all parts. 
They 
> see their experience. Take the 'Bill was cool' line. A friend of 
> mine had only this bit, that he though a couple of boys were cool. 
> He was the first surprised to discover he was bi at 22. Tell him 
> Harry is not a bisexual and he'll look puzzled because he 
> identifies with him at sexual development.

I am a woman who thought certain girls were cool at 15, think and 
tell women they are pretty or have cute figures etc now, and am no 
way in hell gay. Harry thinking Bill is cool is no way gay canon 
fodder. People whether gay or straight admire certain things about 
other people.  
Fran
> 
<snip> In fact I think we were discussing the Harry/Bill subtext, or 
that 
> is where I catched the thread. 
> 
> silmariel