[HPforGrownups] Re: Prophecy Contradiction

[jazmyn]

No: HPFGUIDX 79037


happyduck1979 wrote:
> Emma "punkstarz85" wrote:
>  > The Prophecy states something along the line of Harry or Voldemort
>  > must murder the other for the remaining to live. However unless I'm
>  > forgetting something, in order to do so, they must duel. I can't
>  > see either going silently or unwillingly, can you?
>  >
>  > I'm curious to see how J.K Rowling is going to work around this!

Rachel: 
> There is nothing to work around.  Wizards do not need to duel to kill
> each other... one can sneak up behind the other or take him or her by
> surprise.  More than this, wands battling in my mind means that
> both spells need to be cast at precisely the same moment.  Thus they
> meet in midair and the effect takes place.  There is also the
> possibility that one of the two might at some point need to use a
> wand not their own. >>>


Like Avatar and Black Wolf in the movie Wizards.  Avatar pulled out a 
gun and shot Black Wolf, when everyone thought they would duel it out 
magically.  What WOULD Voldemort do if Harry pulled out a gun and blew 
his head off?  A trigger can be pulled faster then one can say a spell...

I think if JKR pulled that stunt in the books, Ralph Bakshi would sue 
her and her fans would gang up on her and silly string her till she 
resembles a rainbow haystack.

If Volde falls off a cliff, then Disney might sue.. Last minute 
'conversion to good' would be too Darth Vader'ish.

Its going to be near impossible to find a way to kill Voldemort off and 
be original, you know...

Jazmyn