Dumbledore the bug (was: " Dumbledore watching over Harry")

jksunflower2002 mkeller01 at alltel.net
Sat Aug 30 13:07:25 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 79277


> acoteucla wrote:
> 
> > Dumbledore has claimed to have watched Harry
> "closer than he 
> > realizes" during his years at Hogwarts. The best
> explanation to 
> how 
> > he knows so much is that he was there when the
> incidents 
> happened. I 
> > personally favor the idea that Dumbledore is (yet
> another) 
> > unregistered animagus. I think he's the wasp we
> see during 
> Harry's 
> > transfiguration OWL.
> 
Toad wrote: 
> In chapter 16 of PoA while Harry is waiting to take
> his Divination 
> exam; "He settled himself on the floor with his back
> against the 
> wall, listening to a fly buzzing in the sunny
> window."  Could 
> Dumbledore be a multi-animagus? Or does Filch need
> to buy some fly 
> strips?

>Buttercup:
This is possible. Perhaps this is a subtle indication
from JKR, who doesn't want to draw too much attention,
yet knows that she must must show how Dumbledore is
>actually watching over Harry.

>I wonder if there are other passages in the books
where Harry notices a fly or other insects. 


Toad again:
Chapter 20 of GoF:  "He spent the rest of the lesson trying to 
attract small objects toward him under the table with his wand.  He 
managed to make a fly zoom straight into his hand, though he wasn't 
entirely sure that was his prowess at Summoning Charms--perhaps the 
fly was just stupid."

Noticed this while doing a re-read.  Fuel for the fire....if there 
is one anymore.

Toad (not quite ready to give up just yet)






More information about the HPforGrownups archive