[HPforGrownups] Dumbledore the bug (was: " Dumbledore watching over Harry")

[Buttercup]

No: HPFGUIDX 79299


acoteucla wrote:
> > 
> > > Dumbledore has claimed to have watched Harry
> > "closer than he 
> > > realizes" during his years at Hogwarts. The best
> > explanation to 
> > how 
> > > he knows so much is that he was there when the
> > incidents 
> > happened. I 
> > > personally favor the idea that Dumbledore is
> (yet
> > another) 
> > > unregistered animagus. I think he's the wasp we
> > see during 
> > Harry's 
> > > transfiguration OWL.
> > 
> Toad wrote: 
> > In chapter 16 of PoA while Harry is waiting to
> take
> > his Divination 
> > exam; "He settled himself on the floor with his
> back
> > against the 
> > wall, listening to a fly buzzing in the sunny
> > window."  Could 
> > Dumbledore be a multi-animagus? Or does Filch need
> > to buy some fly 
> > strips?
> 
> >Buttercup:
> This is possible. Perhaps this is a subtle
> indication
> from JKR, who doesn't want to draw too much
> attention,
> yet knows that she must must show how Dumbledore is
> >actually watching over Harry.
> 
> >I wonder if there are other passages in the books
> where Harry notices a fly or other insects. 
> 
> 
> Toad again:
> Chapter 20 of GoF:  "He spent the rest of the lesson
> trying to 
> attract small objects toward him under the table
> with his wand.  He 
> managed to make a fly zoom straight into his hand,
> though he wasn't 
> entirely sure that was his prowess at Summoning
> Charms--perhaps the 
> fly was just stupid."
> 
Buttercup:

While rereading OotP, I came up with a new idea. Maybe
it's Fawkes who's watching over Harry for Dumbledore. 
When they're in Dumbledore's office after Harry has
the vision of Mr. Weasley being attacked by a snake,
Dumbledore sends Fawkes to keep a lookout for
Umbridge.  Fawkes probably did this undercover so
Unbridge wouldn't notice, don't you think? Maybe the
bird is doing the same with Harry. Somehow he's spying
on Harry, without Harry knowing. 


=====
Buttercup

__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! SiteBuilder - Free, easy-to-use web site design software
http://sitebuilder.yahoo.com