Red robes green eyes, green robes red eye

arealin alina at distantplace.net
Mon Dec 8 01:44:22 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 86670

> > Wait a minute!  Is it possible that Dumbledore is an ancestor of 
> > Slytherin. If he's pureblood he's got to be.  And the Weasly's 
too. 

"Ancestor" of a person who lived centuries before his time? Now 
that's a very Rowlingian slip!

>I don't fully understand where this is going in the story, but I am
>convinced that before the story ends, we will find great 
>significants in who is related to whom.

I think a lot of the significance of this fact comes through in that 
it is Lily's love for Harry that is protecting him and thus needs to 
be maintained by Harry living in an Evans household. After all, 
James died to protect Harry too, didn't he? But if his love had the 
same effect, then Harry could be placed in any number of wizarding 
households, possibly including the Weasleys! Hmmm Harry raised in a 
loving wizarding environment... no we wouldn't want that, would we?

>I am very convinced that Ollivander is a true die-hard unwavering
>Dumbledore supporter. Remember, the Ollivander family has been in
>business since (something like) 383 B.C.; nearly 2400 years. That's 
>a long time to hold a respected and trusted position in the wizard 
>world.

You know, personally, I'm fairly convinced that the position of a 
respected and trusted wizard comes with neutral territory. In other 
words, I'm pretty sure the Ollivanders could be a family that 
doesn't join and is never asked to join conflicts. Think about it, 
if they were on a side, they could simply refuse to provide wands 
for the other side. Since Ollivander's wands are the best, that 
would give his side an advantage, wouldn't it? So, I'm pretty sure, 
Ollivanders are most likely to be neutral. 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive