OOP: MWPP and their houses/Tonks' purpose

katie_wible tiamik72 at aol.com
Tue Dec 30 17:46:30 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 87784


> 
> I'm sure that the vast majority of the Blacks were Slytherins for 
> generations.  I rather think that Sirius was not.  I can see him 
> being sorted into Gryffindor, and that causing great distress and 
> shame to his parents.  And, of course, then Regulus comes along and 
> assuages some of that feeling by being sorted into Slytherin. The 
> sorting of the brothers becomes one more example of Regulus being 
the 
> perfect son and Sirius being the blood traitor.
> 
> Marianne

Okay,  there is no evidence of this, but wouldn't it be hilarious if 
Sirius was sorted into Hufflepuff. I mean Gryffindor is one thing, at 
least they are brave. But could you imagine Mrs. Black recieving an 
owl saying that her first born son became a Hufflepuff. That would 
probably be an even bigger blow to the family, seeing as they are 
viewed as a bunch of duffers. When it comes to prejudiced people like 
Mrs. Black, I think Hufflepuff would be an even bigger insult than 
Gryffindor.  

They is no evidence to deny that he was in Hufflepuff either. I mean 
he is extremely loyal, and values the friendship thing( about 
sacrificing yourself for your freinds, like they would all have done 
for Peter.) 

I'm not sure about this though, I still think they were all 
Gyffindors, because it would be extremely hard to notice if Lupin was 
gone once a month if they were all in different houses.

sorry for rambling, 
Katie





More information about the HPforGrownups archive