Who told James?

[derannimer <susannahlm@yahoo.com>]

No: HPFGUIDX 51392

Grey Wolf wrote: 

>For all that it's worth, I'm going to muddy the waters by throwing 
>in another possibility: James wasn't told of the prank by anyone: he 
>saw Snape going into the tunnel in the marauders map, and realised 
>at that moment that something was terribly wrong.

Now me: No, that doesn't work; Lupin says "your father, who'd heard 
what Sirius had done." Since he said *heard,* that strongly rules out 
James discovering the Prank by himself. It sounds like he, well, 
heard it.


Derannimer (who thought Elkins's "Peter helped set up the Prank" 
scenario is a scenario she could really go for)