Ginny SHIP: was JKR Interview (what she said and what she didn't say)
pippin_999 <foxmoth@qnet.com>
foxmoth at qnet.com
Thu Feb 13 17:38:14 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 52112
Marina said:
>>>Harry noticing something cool about Ginny would be the
beginning of a process that might lead to a relationship, not the
endpoint. <<<
Well, yeah. This is a book about teenagers in a comparatively
inhibited environment, sexually speaking. I mean, "Dawson's
Creek" it's not. How close to the "endpoint" do you expect them
to get? I don't think I'd be going too far out on a limb to predict
that Harry Potter will not become sexually active while he's a
Hogwarts student.
There are plenty of love stories where the main character madly
pursues the wrong person almost to the final chapter, while
steadfastly ignoring the right person who is pursuing them. After
all, from the author's point of view, the problem is not, "how do I
get these two nice people together", it's "how do I manage to
keep them apart till the end"?
JKR doesn't have the freedom of a fanfic writer as regards her
characters. We aren't going to open book 5 and find that they've
all morphed into fancy free twenty-somethings living "Friends"
style in a fashionable London flat. <g> JKR's made it clear
enough that though she writes for herself, she's not going to put
in anything she feels is inappropriate for a twelve year old.
That's another reason for thinking the main love interest in the
books will be Ron and Hermione. They can slip off to an empty
classroom for a bit of charms work, nudge nudge wink wink,
without compromising anyone's innocence.
I said:
> And saving Ginny's life wasn't a meaningful
> interaction, I guess. Poor Ginny...what does a girl have to go
> through to be meaningful around here?
Marina:
>>>>Something more than just lie there unconscious,
apparently. And
since this event has not come up in conversation between them
even once in the two years that followed it, I think that whatever
significance it might have had, it's certainly not pushing Harry
and Ginny into each other's arms.<<<
"When one wizard saves another wizard's life, it creates a certain
bond between them. <snip> "This is magic at its deepest, its
most impenetrable..." PoA Ch. 22
I don't think JKR would have created a life debt between Ginny
and Harry if it wasn't going to be important. But she might have
her reasons for wanting *us* to ignore it for a while. As that
Aragorn/Arwen Shipper Gandalf put it, "Many folk like to know
beforehand what is to be set on the table; but those who have
laboured to prepare the feast like to keep their secret; for wonder
makes the words of praise louder."
Besides, there's this:
"Ginny?"
"Hermione?"
"What are you doing?"
"I was looking for Ron--"
"Come in and sit down--"
"Not here!" said Harry hurriedly. "*I'm* here."
PoA ch. 5
Certainly sounds as if Ginny's distress over the Dementors
drove her into Harry's arms or maybe his lap, doesn't it? <g>
Now, I know, I know, they're only 12 and 13 in this scene, but it's
much funnier if you think that someday they are going to be
interested in each other. You'll also notice that with every
opportunity to have Hermione fall into Harry, she steps on Ron
instead.
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive