Trelawny Prediction (WAS: Re: Three Missing Death Eaters)

[melclaros <melclaros@yahoo.com>]

No: HPFGUIDX 52911

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, >
 melpomene wrote: 
> >...And my brain does one of those psychodelic double 
> > takes and gloms onto Professor Trelawny's 
comment about that "faithful servant" (there's 
> > that term again) being "chained these twelve years." 


 to which rib responded:
> My own brain did a psychedelic double take when I read this.  
Turned 
> around much of my perspective.  But then I dug out the actual 
quote. 


And that shows us why we shouldn't even try to have real lives, but 
should spend our entire existances trying to fit together this monkey-
puzzle! <grins evilly> Thanks for looking that up, I knew I didn't 
have the whole quote and can't put my hand on the book right now. But 
I do still wonder. At the time of PoA we had 2 prime candidates for 
the Chained Servant. Pettigrew and Black. Then as it turned out, 
there was acutally a THIRD in the wings (Crouch) who was instrumental 
in V's return and who was called (or so we're lead to believe so far) 
his "faithful servant".
All I'm saying is as far as I'm concerned the jury is still out on 
just who was in chains and just what forms those chains took. Is 
there someone ELSE out there we don't know about? Probably.

As for a couple of details you mention:

> 
> Snape can't be applied to (2), (3), and (4): wasn't Snape 
unconscious > and then talking to Dumbledore at this time? (re 
Midnight)

I don't know, was that at Midnight, or before? Again, I have to 
excavate the book. 

>And he has yet to "break free" from the "chains" of Hogwarts.

This may very well be true. Or not. It could be at this point he 
resumes his double agent status.

Melpomene