Foreshadowing Clues in CoS
Tasha <scarlet1912@hotmail.com>
scarlet1912 at hotmail.com
Thu Feb 27 00:59:30 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 52916
Melissa wrote:
>I'm an amateur genealogist and unless Tom Riddle was born well over
>1000
>years ago he couldn't be Slytherin's "ancestor". An ancestor is a
>direct
>line blood relative that goes back through your line (parents,
>grandparents,
>great grandparents ect) while a descendent goes from your line
>forward.
>(children, grandchildren ect). I suspect that she simply got the
>words mixed
>up and it wasn't caught in editing.
And Kathryn wrote:
>It's already been established in interview that it was supposed to
>be heir, or
>that it's supposed to say that Slytherin is Tom Riddle's ancestor.
>Sorry for
>the short post, but we've already talked about this.
Pardon me for my ignorance of your previous topics, I am new here and
I had a silly thought while reading someones post. Also, I believe I
have a good enough grasp on the English language to know what
ancestor means, thank you. Apparently what I wrote after the ancestor
part was not paid attention to. The issue here was whether or not
Voldemort had children and my silly thought was maybe he did and he
named his son Salazar Slytherin which would make him the ancestor of
that SS, not the one who founded Hogwarts. Never did I ever subscribe
to the theory that it wasn't a mistake in wording on JKRs part.
Tasha~ who is making a note to refrain from posting silly ideas here.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive