Against Evil!Lupin responses (long)

[Kelly L. <kethlenda@yahoo.com>]

No: HPFGUIDX 49575

Snuffles wrote, as part of a long and very cool post,

 I also think there is a 
> part of Lupin who may have thought there was a possibility that 
Sirius was 
> not guilty.

I'm going to have to agree.  Otherwise, Lupin wouldn't have so 
quickly jumped to the question "unless you switched...without 
telling me."  If he had believed Sirius unquestionably guilty, there 
would have been a much longer argument about that.  I think 
Lupin always considered the remote possibility that the Potters *
had* switched Secret-Keepers without telling Lupin.  

Kelly L.