[HPforGrownups] Do Grown-Up HP Fans Favor PoA & GoF over PS/SS and CoS?

[Susan XG]

No: HPFGUIDX 49648



>>>>I've always been curious about the differences between the younger HP 
>>>>fans and the adults. <<<<


Excellent topic! I'll comment. I'm 22 and CoS is actually my favorite of the 
HP books. I just thought it was so clever (and I still do after reading it 
four times!). GoF is a close second, mostly because the kids are growing up 
and having to deal with more problems. It's pretty dark, but it's 
appropriate for the subject matter.

PoA is actually my least favorite of the novels. I don't really know why. 
Intitially, I thought it was too dark, but after rereading it again, I 
discovered that I like it better than I did. However, it is still number 4 
in my eyes.

I don't dislike ANY of the novels. That's the challenge. They are each 
unique in their own way and are all excellent. It's really hard to pick 
favorites.

Susan :o)


_________________________________________________________________
MSN 8: advanced junk mail protection and 2 months FREE*. 
http://join.msn.com/?page=features/junkmail