[HPforGrownups] Re: Hagrid and Voldermort

[illyana delorean]

No: HPFGUIDX 49756

>
>Cassie wrote:
>"Priori Incantatem...That couldn't happen if
>Hagrid had Voldie's ORIGINAL wand.
>
>Alex me: 
>But what if Hagrid was just holding it from the
>night he picked up Harry when LV went down at the
>Potters house? He didn't actually use it. What if
>in POA Peter Pettigrew was "hiding" in Hagrids
>house because Hagrid had LVs wand there in his
>home. Peter wanted to steal LVs wand.  Why else
>would he be in Hagrids hut?
>

Are we assuming that, if Hagrid did have LV's wand, he was using it 
in his pink umbrella? If we are, don't we have to consider that 
Hagrid did use the wand for magic a few times, even though he may not 
have verbally uterred the spells? What I mean is, Hagrid used the 
wand when he picked up Harry from the shack-in-the-middle-of-the-sea 
in PS/SS to make the boat move (among other things, if I remember 
correctly). So, although those spells were not ones that Hagrid had 
to speak (he just pointed his wand, I believe), would they not show 
up during Priori Incantatem? If it *was* LV's wand making that boat 
move, wouldn't some sort of ghostly boat come out of the wand and 
confuse everyone in that graveyard?

Of course, Hagrid could have just put LV's wand in his bedside table 
and let it be during that whole time. Although I think it would be 
very interesting if Hagrid was using LV's wand in his pink umbrella, 
I believe it is merely a piece of his wand from his younger years.

illyana
-- 
S1.3 MIL+++ RWG++# FRI++ CBG++ P&S-- f++/+++ n- $++++ 9F13, 1F22, 
2F13, 3F02, 3F05, 4F01, 4F08, 4F11, 4F19 F1980

HPGCv1
a22 e+ x+* Rm Ri HP4 S+++ Mo++ HG+/VK++ HaP+/SS+++& FGW++ DM++& VC-- 
GG-- CD+ VK++ SS+++& PT--- AF-- MM++ RL++ O+m FAo F- Sl FHo SfD

"What's the point in having a Honda if you can't show it off?" - 
Superintendent Chalmers

visit my livejournal! http://www.livejournal.com/users/illyanadmc