Hagrid and Voldermort

[Torsten]

No: HPFGUIDX 49780

illyana:

>What I mean is, Hagrid used the 
>wand when he picked up Harry from the shack-in-the-middle-of-the-sea 
>in PS/SS to make the boat move (among other things, if I remember 
>correctly). So, although those spells were not ones that Hagrid had 
>to speak (he just pointed his wand, I believe), would they not show 
>up during Priori Incantatem? If it *was* LV's wand making that boat 
>move, wouldn't some sort of ghostly boat come out of the wand and 
>confuse everyone in that graveyard?

Not even all of Voldemort's recent spells showed up. There was the hand he made for 
Pettigrew and the AKs, but it's doubtful wether the "screams of pain" the wand emits 
stand for the Crucio spells he cast on Harry, and there's no sign of the Imperio spells at 
all, even though he cast plenty of these (on Harry, Crouch Sr., probably Bertha).

What bothers me most about the "Hagrid had LV's wand"-theory: Hagrid's not the type 
of person to keep something that belonged to Voldemort. He's afraid of speaking the 
name, he would feel very uncomfortable about keeping the wand. And why should 
Dumbledore want him to keep it in the first place? Why not destroy it? There's nothing 
to be gained from keeping it, it just makes it possible for Voldy to get it back which 
can't be in Dumbledore's interest.
And while nobody might suspect Hagrid's hut is where it kept, it would still be safer in 
Dumbledore's rooms or some hiding place no one knows about.

Torsten