[HPforGrownups] Re: What will come in book 5

Maria Kirilenko maria_kirilenko at yahoo.com
Thu Jan 23 23:37:05 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 50427


--- "Kathy <pkdailey at comcast.net>"
<pkdailey at comcast.net> wrote:
> I think that the "death that will be hard to write"
> is going to be 
> Lupin.  I say this because JKR has admitted in her
> interview with 
> scholastic that Lupin is one of her favorite
> characters.  Perhaps 
> Lupin fights Voldemort and loses.  Lupin's death
> would be very hard 
> to write, given that he is such a good guy.  He is
> also very close 
> to Harry, and someone that Harry greatly admires. 
> Think of the plot 
> consequences! I also think that there are more
> deaths than one.  JKR 
> said as much, didn't she?
> 

Noooooo! I don't even want to think about it. It would
be so unfair, to him and to us.


> Hermione and Harry are not attracted to one another.
>  Teenage 
> romance is characterized by awkwardness and
> embarrassment.  Hermione 
> kisses Harry on the cheek (a very common practice in
> Europe) without 
> any signs of awkwardness or embarrassment.  This
> leads me to believe 
> that Hermione views Harry as a brother or close
> friend.  

While it's arguable that Hermione likes/doesn't like
Harry (and I don't even want to be dragged into this
<g>), I think that it's obvious Harry does not like
Hermione *that way.* Do I even need to back this up
with quotes? He never bats an eyelash when he realizes
Ron likes Hermione.

 
> Another reason I think that Ginny and Harry will end
> up together has 
> its roots in history.  They are linked though their
> history with Tom 
> Riddle and the CoS.  Harry wants more than anything
> to be part of a 
> family because he never had much of a family of his
> own (who counts 
> the Dursleys?).  In a sense, Ginny's family is
> already Harry's 
> family.  He is an honorary Weasly already, and
> linking Harry and 
> Ginny would give Harry a sense of belonging and
> family that he has 
> always wanted.  Would he have that with Hermione? 
> No, not to the 
> same extent or with the same significance that he
> would have with 
> Ginny.  Linking Harry with Ginny and Ron with
> Hermione would, in a 
> way, make them brothers and all of them family.  I
> just think that 
> from a literary perspective, this makes the best
> sense.  That's just 
> my opinion?


Oh my gosh. I just realized this - Ginny has a
life-debt to Harry! I wonder how she's going to pay
him back.

Maria

__________________________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail Plus - Powerful. Affordable. Sign up now.
http://mailplus.yahoo.com




More information about the HPforGrownups archive