Voldemort and Slytherin
Tom Wall <thomasmwall@yahoo.com>
thomasmwall at yahoo.com
Mon Jan 27 13:11:06 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 50773
"Slytherin, according to the legend, sealed the Chamber of Secrets so
that none would be able to open it until his own true heir arrived at
the school." Professor Binns (CoS 151)
Does anyone have any idea why Slytherin's descendants weren't watched
with the utmost scrutiny?
Obviously, the rumor of the Chamber of Secrets was enough to cause
many wizards and witches to search for its location in the school.
In other words, they took it seriously enough to believe it might be
there. So, if they took it seriously enough to entertain notions of
its existence, how come they didn't take it seriously enough to trace
Slytherin's lineage through to the present day?
After all, Riddle's mother would have also been a descendent of
Slytherin. In fact, there were probably tons of descendents of
Salazar Slytherin. There are any number of generations between
Slytherin and Riddle. And the likelihood of there being a single-to-
single family tree is pretty minimal, I mean, one-to-one all the way
down *is* a fairly rare occurance. And although we don't know this as
fact, we must assume that some, if not all of them attended Hogwarts.
So with all of those generations of little Slytherins bouncing
around, why was Riddle the only one to open the Chamber of Secrets?
I can only settle on three solutions:
1) Slytherin's descendents didn't attend Hogwarts until Riddle did
(this seems totally ridiculous to me.)
2) The other descendents didn't figure out that they were Slytherin's
heirs (this also seems silly to me.)
2) Riddle was the only one who was a Parselmouth, since that's
supposed to be a very rare ability, so it's possible that none of the
other descendents possessed the skill.
I like three the most, but it still doesn't settle well.
All the same, it just seems, well, *irresponsible* to not follow all
of Slytherin's descendents very closely, particularly if they
attended Hogwarts, knowing that there was a potential for said 'heir'
to unleash evil upon the school.
-Tom
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive