What to do with the stone
gingersnape1966 <gingersnape1966@yahoo.com>
gingersnape1966 at yahoo.com
Fri Jan 31 12:04:55 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 51240
This started out with a post re: House points and Dumbledore. I have
been up and down the thread and have not been able to find the
message that got me started thinking on this. I appologize to
whomever it was as I am unable to give credit. I also appologize if
this has been discussed before.
So (finally) to my point: What did Harry intend to do with the stone
after he got it? He went down to get it assuming that he was keeping
it from Snape rather than Quirrel, but the end recipient would have
been the same.
He knew Dumbledore was on his way to the Ministry. McGonagall had
been quite stern in telling him that he was to forget about it. What
was he planning to do? Stuff it in the pocket of his jammies, wander
back to Gryffindor Tower and have a nice nap, waiting until the next
day to say, "oh, by the way, Headmaster, here's the stone you've
spent the last year devising ways of protecting. I got it out for
you."? Wake McGonagall and ask her to keep it in her nightstand?
Feed it to Fluffy with the assumption that all good things must come
to pass? How on earth did he think that getting it *away* from the
protection would keep it safer?
It never occured to me. That's what I love about this site.
Ginger
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive