OOP: Life Debt?
Tom Wall
thomasmwall at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 3 03:32:49 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 66949
Maggie B. wrote:
<snip earlier stuff>
Also, so much was going on in that room, how do we know that Sirius
didn't, I don't know, step between Bellatrix and Harry as she
yelled "Avada Kedavra"? That would make the life debt even more
evident.
Tom replies:
I think we can be fairly certain that she didn't use Avada Kedavra
because the color of the spell that hit him was red, and Avada
Kedavra results in a green light. That, and the observation that
Sirius didn't die when the spell hit him - his "eyes widened in
shock." (OoP, Ch.35, 805, US edition)
As we know from GoF (both when Crouch!Moody uses it on the spider,
and when it's used later on Cedric) a successful Avada Kedavra
immediately kills the recipient, leaving no signs of physical
stress; the person simply drops dead. If Sirius' eyes widened, I'd
say that he didn't immediately die from the spell. I think that he
died because he accidentally fell through the veil, which appears to
represent some kind of entrance to "death."
-Tom
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive