OOP: "ARGH!" the List, the Names, The Room, and the Future too.

[Steve]

No: HPFGUIDX 67836

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Kirstini" <kirst_inn at y...> wrote:
> Steve wrote:> ...
>  It's the 'Room of REQUIREMENTS'! It's a room that manufactures or
> creates what ever you require. ... If you needed evidence
> to convict someone; the room would create the evidence.>
> 
> ***
> But it doesn't create. Not at all. It Summons. ...edited..
>
> Kirstini

bboy_mn:

Yes, but Umbridge and Fudge don't know that. Dumbledore, based on his
own statements, is only marginally knowledgable about the room. And,
that means the 'what you need' assertion could be demonstrated well
enough to confuse the issue and cast doubt on the evidence.

Basically, it would be a desperate story that Harry would attempt to
use to discredit the evidence. All he needs to do is demonstrate that
if he needs food, the room will give him food; if he needs a bathroom,
it will give him a bathroom, which creates the next logical assumption
that if you need evidence, it creates evidence.

Someone in another post wondered why the room stayed the way it was.
Why did it continue to be the D.A. practice room then the Slytherin
went in and found the names list? Because that persona and Umbridge
needed the room to be Harry's D.A. practice room.


Slightly off subject, how many people believe Harry will continue the
D.A. leasons the next year, and how many believe it will continue to
be the core group with a couple others added, and how many think it
will become an open to the whole school club, and will that include
Slytherins?

Just a thought.

bboy_mn