[HPforGrownups] Dobby's behavior explained?/Harry blood relative to Malfoy family

Robert A. Rosenberg rarpsl at optonline.net
Tue Jul 8 21:11:17 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 68482

At 03:16 +0000 on 07/08/2003, Brian wrote about [HPforGrownups] 
Dobby's behavior explained?/Harry blood rel:

>This would explain how Dobby was able to do what he did...and it
>gives Harry a blood relationship to the Malfoy family...How this
>pertains to the story line,I am not sure.  But is certainly can open
>several different paths of disscussion.

Why not the Black Family instead (that link would make him related to 
the Malfoy family by marriage [via Narcissa]). Remember that there 
were deleted entries in the Black Family tree due to "defections" to 
the Good Guys. Why not a Son or Daughter marrying into the Potter or 
Evans family? We still have no info on the Evans (who could be a 
Wizard Family prone to having squib offspring thus explaining Lilly's 
Parents joy at her being a Witch). Marrying into such a family would 
IMO be grounds for the removal. Note that both Narcissa [Narcissus] 
and Bellatrix [Belladonna] are flower names so Lily and Petunia would 
fit in with the style if their Mother were an excommunicated Black.


At 16:26 +0000 07/08/2003, Brian wrote about [HPforGrownups] Re: 
Dobby's behavior explained?/Harry blood:
>If you read Kreachers story and follow his actions through the book
>and listen to dialoge by DD and Serius I believe there is a clear
>possibility that Dobby in COS was acting the same way...The next big
>revelation is that Harry is going to be related to the Malfoy family.

See my above comment about a way for him to have a Malfoy connection.


--

Bob Rosenberg





More information about the HPforGrownups archive