Dobby's behavior explained?/Harry blood relative to Malfoy family

Susan Smith atroposgryffin at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 10 03:27:42 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 68926

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Robert A. Rosenberg" 
<rarpsl at o...> wrote:
> At 03:16 +0000 on 07/08/2003, Brian wrote about [HPforGrownups] 
> Dobby's behavior explained?/Harry blood rel:
> 
> >This would explain how Dobby was able to do what he did...and it
> >gives Harry a blood relationship to the Malfoy family...How this
> >pertains to the story line,I am not sure.  But is certainly can 
open
> >several different paths of disscussion.
> 
> Why not the Black Family instead (that link would make him related 
to the Malfoy family by marriage [via Narcissa]). Remember that there 
were deleted entries in the Black Family tree due to "defections" to 
the Good Guys. Narcissa [Narcissus] and Bellatrix [Belladonna] are 
flower names so Lily and Petunia would fit in with the style if their 
Mother were an excommunicated Black.
> 
<Atropos G.>

Narcissa literally translates to Daffodil.  Bellatrix literally means 
female warrior and is a star.  However, we seem to be thinking along 
similar lines because this has been discussed previously how strange 
that Andromeda and Bellatrix are stars/constellations while Narcissa 
is a flower.  Perhaps she is related to Lilly and Petunia-why does 
the Evans family chose to name people after flowers and the Black 
family after stars/constellations?  This may be red herring, but JKR 
spent an awful lot of time laying out the Black family tree and 
sharing with us the many thoughts on intermarriages so the pure blood 
lines would not die out-I think something will come of this.

A.G.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive