Snape eating or not eating

melclaros melclaros at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 9 15:00:59 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 68680

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Kirstini" <kirst_inn at y...> 
wrote:
> <Snip lots of reasons why Snape is never seen eating at Grimmauld 
> Place: Vampiracy, Suspiscion, Pureblood conventions, Florence in a 
> flowery pinny holding Little Sev, eating with his dear old mum 
> instead>
> 
> I think that someone proposed another reason when this topic came 
up 
> immediatly post-OoP, concerning warrior culture. The theory was 
that 
> Snape wouldn't eat/accept hospitality at the house of his enemy, 
> because that would put him in said enemy's debt. Another one 
> suggests itself to me too: he simply didn't like the company. The 
> only person we see him having any sort of interaction which could 
> possibly be construed as friendly with at all is McGonagall, and 
she 
> only made one visit to Grimmauld Place over the summer (evidence 
for 
> a possible Mr McGonagall? I do hope he's called William). It would 
> be very difficult for Snape to maintain his strange and not-
terribly-
> wonderful relationship (for whatever reason it exists) with HRH 
> after crushing a cup of wine with them. 
> 

Plus--he has a job to do. Remember what Lupin said when he and Black 
were bemoaning how little they could do? Black couldn't leave the 
house and Lupin wasn't a "popular dinner guest" (his words). Snape is 
likely BOOKED for dinner most of the time with the cronies he's 
spying on and the one's he's trying to get a feel for what side 
they're leaning towards. He's not just a spy, he's a lobbyist.
When he is free I go with the "never eat in the house of your enemy" 
idea. I can't imagine why he'd WANT to stay for dinner with that 
crowd. Perhaps if it were only the adults, but all the Weasly kids 
and later Potter? Eeyuuch!

Melpomene





More information about the HPforGrownups archive